Chair Perry Brown stated he appreciates the work that Cade Visser and staff put into this in reformulating the ordinance. This describes the process of obtaining or renewing a business license and sets conditions to Type 1 and Type 2 impacts, and whether or not we have administrative approval with possible conditions mitigating any adverse impacts. Cade Visser stated he took the recommendations made at last meeting, took out impacts that might not be needed and came up with a table of impacts. Type 1 business owner's impacts will be related to employees, traffic, parking and potential nuisances. If you can meet all these impacts, we'd keep it under Type 1 and issue a license. If you are an office, like a CPA for example, and never have anyone come in, you are exempt. If you still want a business license, we can issue one and have you on your merry way. The previous version at the last meeting was about when you couldn't meet these impacts which determined whether you could have a business license or not. With a Type 2, if you may be potentially impacting beyond those initial impacts, your hopes and dreams don't die, but you may have to go through the process of meeting to see if the zoning is correct. There may still be questions by the TRC and to be classified as a Type 2, TRC would look over the application and mitigate impacts before it needs to come to the Planning Commission. Then City Manager would certify it or see if Planning Commission needs to see it as a Conditional Use Permit. If that is the case it would be the same process we currently have for Conditional Use Permits. What we talked about last meeting is this process provides flexibility, but it may also provides for more lengthy requirements. This would require more effort and presentation. Each year they would come in and certify if anything has materially changed they are still under the rules of the Type 1 or their Type 2 Conditional Use Permit. If they are no longer meeting that, they would either need to scale down their operation, or possibly move to a different location. We tried to not regulate more than we need to but provide clarity for the business owner and other property owners. We tried to keep those quantitative metrics in. We would like to go through this so that maybe next meeting we can have a public hearing and keep the process rolling. Chair Perry Brown stated in order to move in this direction, it was really necessary to separate between Type 1 and Type 2. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated that he doesn't know how many people would fall in to a Type 2 review. Cade Visser stated he would say the majority of businesses would be a Type 1. This net they cast is not strict, but it allows us to look at what is our maximum capacity that should be a store front or if it belongs in a commercial business area. Commissioner Pam Gardiol stated that she is impressed with Cade Visser and staff's wholistic view on this, and building in the possibility for communication with the applicant. She likes that it could go to the TRC for review and then come to the Commission. There are places to collaborate while respecting the feel of a neighborhood. Commissioner Dave Robinson had stated last meeting that there are generational changes here and how Ivins started as a farming community. The Cottonmill years ago in Washington was a home-based business. My Grandmother who lived in Delta had a small manufacturing company. My mother was the distributor of her slippers. My mother had two small businesses in our home, a financial business and one in health care. She herself has had an international business she ran out of her home for 30 years. Is it the tools that we use in the home-based business that decides what type they qualify for? It still comes back to whether we have a feel of a neighborhood while we are living our lives. She likes that this ordinance has time for discussion and tries to protect both the quality of life we want in our neighborhoods and gives people the opportunity to realize their dreams. This is a nice mix of that. Chair Perry Brown stated there is a notion that so many people work from home now, but that is not necessarily their own home-based business. There are a lot of people working from home that is not for their own business. You have accommodated that within this and he appreciates that change. Working for someone else is not a home-based business. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated this was a positive change because it allows the majority of people to go through the more simplified Type 1 process. Did you look at other communities and what they have done? Cade Visser stated yes. Commissioner Doug Clifford inquired if this concept was common? Cade Visser stated no, one other City required a Conditional Use Permit every time. Not many other cities went down this route. The positive of this is the flexibility and collaboration. The list helps expedite in black and white what someone can do. Chair Perry Brown stated this may take a little more time, but it is not a long involved discussion about individual items. If the reviewer says it fits, a business license will be issued. Cade Visser stated if we look at everything under one blanket and not taking the time to collaborate, then it may or may not fit in one area. But this gives us an opportunity to look at it and make something work. Chair Perry Brown inquired on Section 5.03.104(2)(f) Line 70 states "a description of equipment, machinery, vehicles, materials, chemicals, inventory, and outdoor activities associated with the business;" would this trigger something to be looked at for any storage equipment and materials? Because 5.03.104(6)(c) also mentions storage areas. Should the wording be similar to be consistent to include storage of materials and equipment in both places? Cade Visser stated he will fix. Commissioner Doug Clifford inquired if people come in and go to a Type 2 and do a Conditional Use Permit, do they have that guidance? Chuck Gillette stated TRC gets it first and they say whether it can be reasonably mitigated. There are review standards on 5.03.104 (8) on Line 113. Bryan Pack stated Line 83 it states that TRC recommends, so either Staff or the Planning Commission reviews it beyond there. We don't want TRC to do it just so it wouldn't have to be an open meeting. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated it is an untried gray area we will have to navigate. Bryan Pack stated it is not much different than a Class IV Conditional Use Permit. The analysis is essentially the same. This would just happen to be for a home-based businesses. Chuck Gillette stated if the impact can't be mitigated then it doesn't belong there. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated it will come down to opinions. Bryan Pack stated opinions based on evidence. There have to be findings. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated that he doesn't think we need a huge Table of Uses, but there will be people who disagree on this. Bryan Pack stated the other approach was a black/white standard with no flexibility or discretion. This one is more reasonable and reasonable people can differ on what that is. He is not worried about it on the City's side as long as we base decisions on findings and supported by Staff. You just have to work through what those reasonable conditions are. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated over time, those first cases will become law and then will now be the standard. Commissioner Brandon Weight stated thank you for this document. The approach is that most of these will be a simple Type 1 and it will be irregular to have a Type 2. He respects Commissioner Doug Clifford's points, but those would be rare, few and far between. If Staff still has the human evaluation and even if it was black/white a person still evaluates if it meets that. This approach allows for a responsibility to our community and neighbors and has flexibility and covers all the different options for at-home businesses while giving the City discretion to identify those that need to move to a commercial location. Commissioner Doug Clifford stated he thinks this is a great way to do it. Law by effective cases is a great way to do it. He thinks that is fine, but be aware that is what will happen. Over time we will get conflicting applications. Chuck Gillette stated he was hesitant when we headed down this road. Kudos to Cade Visser and to Bryan Pack for helping. It is reasonable and has enough friction to be a Type 2 business. It is reasonable for those larger businesses to be more heavily scrutinized. Council may think it is a bad idea and they may go back to the original ordinance but this is a good prototype. This is the Planning Commission's own ordinance that came from your own ideas. Commissioner Pam Gardiol stated Line 111 she would like Planning Commission capitalized, Line 114, 125 and 129. Bryan Pack stated our Code doesn't capitalize those defined terms. It doesn't affect the enforceability. Commissioner Pam Gardiol asked to just make them consistent. Line 147 Table of Impacts was capitalized elsewhere. She commended Cade Visser and Bryan Pack for what they have done and it is a good faith effort. Chair Perry Brown stated clean it up a bit and get it on the Planning Commission for next meeting. Chuck Gillette stated hopefully you all saw the provision that identified a grandfathering option for existing businesses. Commissioner Pam Gardiol stated she likes it. Chair Perry Brown stated it was appropriate. We don't want to toss out the past. When businesses come through we will see if they are in compliance or not.